15 Underrated Midwestern Cities That Are Absolutely Killing It in the Food Scene

1. Indianapolis, Indiana

iStock

Indianapolis has seen a remarkable transformation in its culinary landscape, according to Brian Garrido from Eater. Long-standing establishments like St. Elmo Steak House continue to impress, while newcomers such as Julieta and Sam’s Square Pie add fresh flavors to the mix. The city’s diverse population has introduced global cuisines, with eateries like Chin Brothers and El Sabor Catracho offering authentic international dishes. This blend of tradition and innovation makes Indianapolis a vibrant food destination.

The city’s food halls, such as The AMP and The Garage, have become popular spots for food enthusiasts, offering a variety of culinary delights under one roof. Additionally, Indianapolis has a rich history of distinctive local dishes, including the pork tenderloin sandwich and sugar cream pie. The city’s growing craft beer scene, with about 50 craft brewers, adds to its culinary appeal. Notably, Condé Nast Traveler once named Indianapolis the “most underrated food city in the U.S.”

2. Madison, Wisconsin

iStock

Madison’s food culture is deeply rooted in its agricultural surroundings and ethnic history. The city’s proximity to dairy farms has led to a rich tradition of cheesemaking, with local specialties like fried cheese curds and hot and spicy cheese bread delighting locals and visitors alike. The Dane County Farmers’ Market, held around Capitol Square, is the largest producer-only farmers’ market in the country, showcasing the region’s bounty. Additionally, Madison’s numerous Wisconsin-style supper clubs offer classic dishes like all-you-can-eat Friday night fish fries, reflecting the city’s culinary heritage.

The city’s vibrant food truck scene adds to its diverse culinary offerings, with vendors serving everything from Korean tacos to gourmet grilled cheese, as Aislyn Greene shares in AFAR. Madison’s commitment to farm-to-table dining is evident in restaurants like L’Etoile, which sources ingredients directly from local farms. The city’s craft beer culture is thriving, with breweries like Ale Asylum and Karben4 Brewing offering unique brews. Madison’s culinary scene is a testament to its blend of tradition and innovation.

3. Dayton, Ohio

iStock

Dayton offers a unique and evolving culinary scene that reflects its rich history and community spirit, according to David Nilsen from Eater. The city is home to distinctive Dayton-style pizza, characterized by a thin, crisp crust and edge-to-edge toppings, with local favorites like Cassano’s and Marion’s Piazza leading the way. Fine dining establishments such as The Pine Club, a nationally recognized steakhouse, add to the city’s diverse food offerings. Additionally, Dayton has a growing craft beer scene, with numerous breweries contributing to its vibrant culinary landscape.

Local specialties like Esther Price Candies and Mike-sells potato chips highlight Dayton’s contribution to America’s snack culture. The city’s food festivals, such as the Dayton Greek Festival and the Italian Fall Festa, celebrate its diverse ethnic communities. The 2nd Street Market offers a variety of local produce and artisanal foods, making it a hub for food enthusiasts. Dayton’s culinary scene is a delightful mix of traditional flavors and modern innovations.

4. Grand Rapids, Michigan

iStock

Grand Rapids has quietly become a haven for food lovers, earning the nickname “Beer City USA” due to its impressive number of craft breweries. The city’s culinary scene is bolstered by its proximity to fertile farmland, providing chefs with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, according to Elyssa Goldberg from Bon Appetit. Restaurants like The Sovengard focus on Scandinavian-inspired dishes using Michigan produce, while Marie Catrib’s offers a fusion of Mediterranean and American flavors. The Downtown Market Grand Rapids is a foodie’s paradise, featuring various vendors and a teaching kitchen.

The city’s annual Restaurant Week showcases its diverse culinary talents, offering diners the chance to experience multiple eateries at special prices. Grand Rapids’ commitment to sustainability is evident in its farm-to-table dining options, with establishments like Grove leading the charge. The Fulton Street Farmers Market, operating since 1922, provides residents and visitors with access to fresh, local produce. Grand Rapids’ blend of craft beverages and innovative cuisine makes it a standout in the Midwest food scene.

5. Des Moines, Iowa

iStock

Des Moines has experienced a culinary renaissance, transforming into a vibrant food destination, according to Hannah Agran from Midwest Living. The city’s Downtown Farmers’ Market is one of the nation’s best, offering a wide array of local produce, artisanal goods, and international cuisines. Restaurants like Alba and Proof showcase the city’s commitment to innovative dining, blending local ingredients with global flavors. The East Village neighborhood has become a hotspot for food enthusiasts, with eateries like Zombie Burger drawing crowds for their creative takes on classic dishes.

The city’s annual Food & Wine Festival attracts chefs and foodies from across the country, highlighting Des Moines’ growing reputation in the culinary world. Local establishments such as Fong’s Pizza offer unique fusion dishes, combining Asian flavors with traditional pizza. Des Moines’ craft beer scene is flourishing, with breweries like Exile Brewing Company leading the way. The city’s dedication to culinary excellence is evident in its diverse and ever-evolving food landscape.

6. Omaha, Nebraska

iStock

Omaha’s food scene is a delightful surprise, offering a mix of classic and contemporary culinary experiences. The city is renowned for its steakhouses, with establishments like Gorat’s Steak House serving up hearty Midwestern fare. However, Omaha’s culinary offerings extend beyond beef; the Old Market district is filled with diverse restaurants, from French cafes to sushi bars. Block 16, known for its inventive sandwiches, has garnered national attention, even earning praise from celebrity chefs.

The city’s food trucks have added a new dimension to its culinary landscape, offering everything from gourmet grilled cheese to Ethiopian cuisine. Omaha’s annual Restaurant Week encourages locals and visitors to explore its diverse dining options at discounted prices. The city’s commitment to local produce is evident in its farmers’ markets, providing chefs with fresh ingredients to craft their menus. Omaha’s blend of tradition and innovation makes it a noteworthy destination for food enthusiasts.

7. Milwaukee, Wisconsin

iStock

Milwaukee’s culinary scene is as diverse as its rich cultural heritage. Known for its German roots, the city boasts numerous establishments serving traditional dishes like bratwurst and schnitzel. However, Milwaukee has embraced a wide range of cuisines, with neighborhoods like Walker’s Point offering a plethora of dining options, from Mexican to Asian fusion. The Milwaukee Public Market is a hub for food lovers, featuring vendors selling everything from fresh seafood to artisanal chocolates.

The city’s brewing history is celebrated through its numerous craft breweries, with establishments like Lakefront Brewery offering tours and tastings. Milwaukee’s annual festivals, such as Summerfest and German Fest, provide opportunities to indulge in local and international cuisines. The city’s commitment to farm-to-table dining is evident in restaurants like Braise, which sources ingredients from local farms. Milwaukee’s culinary landscape is a testament to its ability to honor tradition while embracing innovation.

8. Minneapolis, Minnesota

Shutterstock

Minneapolis has become one of the most exciting food cities in the Midwest, blending Scandinavian traditions with a growing multicultural influence. The city’s famed Juicy Lucy burger, a cheese-stuffed delight, can be found at spots like Matt’s Bar and The 5-8 Club, each claiming to have invented it. The Midtown Global Market is a vibrant hub of international flavors, from Somali sambusas to Mexican tamales. Restaurants like Owamni, which focuses on Indigenous cuisine, highlight the city’s commitment to culinary storytelling.

The Twin Cities’ craft beer scene is thriving, with breweries like Surly and Indeed Brewing Company drawing beer lovers from across the country. Minneapolis’ farm-to-table movement is strong, with eateries like Spoon and Stable sourcing directly from regional farms. Food halls such as Malcolm Yards and Keg and Case Market provide even more options for adventurous diners. Whether you’re craving Nordic flavors, innovative fine dining, or bold global dishes, Minneapolis delivers on all fronts.

9. Kansas City, Missouri

iStock

Kansas City has long been famous for its barbecue, and for good reason—joints like Joe’s Kansas City Bar-B-Que and Q39 serve some of the best smoked meats in the country. But beyond burnt ends and ribs, the city’s food scene has evolved into something much bigger. Restaurants like Corvino and The Antler Room are pushing the boundaries of fine dining with inventive menus and fresh, local ingredients. The historic River Market area is home to a thriving farmers’ market and a mix of global eateries offering everything from Vietnamese pho to Middle Eastern falafel.

The city’s cocktail culture is also booming, with speakeasies like Julep and The Monarch creating craft concoctions that pair perfectly with its rich food scene. Kansas City’s Latin American food is also making waves, with standout spots like Poio serving wood-fired Mexican chicken. The city’s culinary diversity is further reflected in its growing sushi, ramen, and vegan food movements. While barbecue will always be king, Kansas City is proving it has so much more to offer food lovers.

10. Columbus, Ohio

iStock

Columbus is one of the fastest-growing food cities in the Midwest, fueled by a young, diverse population eager to experiment with flavors. The Short North Arts District is packed with trendy eateries, including Service Bar, which showcases locally sourced dishes with bold twists. The city is also home to Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams, which started in Columbus before becoming a national sensation. North Market is a must-visit, housing a mix of vendors serving everything from Tibetan dumplings to Nashville-style hot chicken.

Columbus has also become a hotspot for international cuisine, particularly Somali, Ethiopian, and Vietnamese food. Local favorite Momo Ghar serves up some of the best dumplings in the region, while restaurants like Lalibela bring authentic Ethiopian flavors to the table. The brewery scene is booming, with places like Seventh Son and Wolf’s Ridge Brewing crafting some of the Midwest’s best beers. With an ever-expanding dining scene and a commitment to innovation, Columbus is quickly becoming a culinary powerhouse.

11. St. Louis, Missouri

iStock

St. Louis may be known for its toasted ravioli and gooey butter cake, but its food scene has expanded far beyond those classics. The city’s Italian neighborhood, The Hill, still serves up legendary plates of pasta, but newer hotspots like Nudo House are bringing incredible ramen and Asian fusion dishes to the forefront. BBQ lovers can indulge at spots like Pappy’s Smokehouse, while vegan-friendly eateries like Lulu’s Local Eatery show the city’s diverse offerings. St. Louis-style pizza, with its cracker-thin crust and Provel cheese, remains a local favorite at institutions like Imo’s.

The city’s brewery game is strong, with stalwarts like Schlafly Beer leading the way alongside innovative newcomers. Cherokee Street has become a go-to spot for Mexican cuisine, with taquerias serving up some of the best street tacos in the Midwest. The city is also home to nationally recognized fine dining at places like Vicia, which emphasizes vegetable-forward cuisine. St. Louis is proving it’s not just a baseball town—it’s a serious food city, too.

12. Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Shutterstock

Sioux Falls may not be the first place that comes to mind for a culinary adventure, but its food scene is a hidden gem. The city has a surprising number of top-tier restaurants, with places like Parker’s Bistro offering elegant dishes in a cozy setting. South Dakota’s agricultural roots are reflected in its farm-to-table dining, with restaurants like M.B. Haskett featuring fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Sioux Falls also boasts a strong craft beer culture, with breweries like Fernson Brewing Company making waves.

The city’s international food scene is also expanding, with a growing number of Asian, Ethiopian, and Latin American restaurants. Sanaa’s serves up some of the best Mediterranean food in the Midwest, while Look’s Marketplace blends butcher shop expertise with innovative dining. The food truck scene is gaining traction, with options ranging from Korean BBQ to gourmet grilled cheese. Sioux Falls may be small, but its culinary offerings are big on flavor.

13. Fargo, North Dakota

Shutterstock

Fargo is quietly becoming a foodie destination, blending its Scandinavian roots with modern culinary trends. The city is home to Nichole’s Fine Pastry, where you’ll find incredible French pastries alongside traditional Nordic treats. The restaurant scene is booming, with spots like Mezzaluna offering upscale dining and Luna serving farm-to-table fare with a Midwestern twist. Fargo also has a growing craft beer movement, with breweries like Drekker Brewing Company creating innovative, bold-flavored beers.

Fargo’s love for comfort food shines through in its hearty, home-cooked dishes, but there’s also room for adventurous eats. The Boiler Room serves an unforgettable tater tot hot dish, while BernBaum’s combines Jewish deli traditions with Scandinavian influences. The Red River Market showcases local farmers and artisanal products, adding to the city’s culinary appeal. Fargo may be best known for cold winters, but its food scene is heating up fast.

14. Toledo, Ohio

Shutterstock

Toledo has been quietly building an impressive food reputation, thanks to its mix of classic and contemporary dining. Tony Packo’s, famous for its Hungarian hot dogs, remains a must-visit institution, but the city has much more to offer. Restaurants like The Heights provide breathtaking skyline views alongside expertly crafted dishes, while Balance Pan-Asian Grille brings fresh, fast, and flavorful fusion food to the mix. The Warehouse District has become a hub for craft breweries, trendy cafés, and unique dining experiences.

The city’s proximity to Lake Erie means fresh seafood is always on the menu, with spots like Real Seafood Company leading the charge. Toledo also has a strong Lebanese food scene, with restaurants like The Beirut offering authentic Middle Eastern flavors. The craft beer and cocktail movement is thriving, adding an extra layer to the city’s culinary growth. Toledo’s underrated food scene is finally getting the attention it deserves.

15. Duluth, Minnesota

iStock

Duluth might be known for its stunning Lake Superior views, but its food scene is just as impressive. The city has embraced locally sourced, sustainable ingredients, with restaurants like New Scenic Café offering beautifully plated dishes with a Nordic influence. The Duluth Grill is a beloved institution, serving hearty yet creative comfort food made from scratch. Lake Avenue Restaurant and Bar takes full advantage of the region’s fresh fish and wild game, making for a true Northwoods dining experience.

Duluth’s craft beer culture is thriving, thanks to local favorites like Bent Paddle Brewing Company. The city’s love for breakfast food is evident at spots like At Sara’s Table Chester Creek Café, where you’ll find some of the best pancakes around. Pier B Resort’s Silos Restaurant offers incredible waterfront dining, pairing fresh seafood with stunning sunsets. Whether you’re in the mood for fine dining or casual bites, Duluth’s food scene is a perfect match for its breathtaking scenery.

Scroll to Top