1. Life Savers Holes
The Life Savers Holes were exactly what they sounded like: mini Life Savers that came in the form of little candy rings. They had all the flavor of the classic Life Saver, but in a fun, snackable form that made them easier to enjoy while on the go. They were discontinued, but the memory of their portability and sweetness remains.
2. Cherry Mash
Cherry Mash was a nostalgic favorite that combined rich milk chocolate, smooth fondant, and a delicious cherry filling. With its unique blend of sweet chocolate and tangy fruit, it was a candy that stood out from the typical chocolate bars of the time. It was a beloved regional treat, particularly in the Midwest, but over the years, it became harder to find on shelves.
3. Sky Bar
Sky Bar was a unique candy bar that offered four distinct sections, each with a different filling: caramel, peanut butter, fudge, and a crispy center. It was the candy bar that gave you a little bit of everything, making it a favorite for those who couldn’t decide between flavors. Sky Bar had a charming, retro vibe and stood out from the crowd with its segmented design. Despite its popularity, it was eventually discontinued, though it remains a nostalgic favorite for candy lovers who appreciate variety in one bite.
4. Mallo Cups
Mallo Cups were a sweet combination of fluffy marshmallow, rich chocolate, and a crunchy peanut butter base. These bite-sized treats were loved for their perfect balance of textures—chewy, creamy, and crunchy all in one bite. While they were available for years, Mallo Cups were eventually discontinued in some places, much to the dismay of marshmallow and peanut butter lovers.
5. Flying Saucer Candy
Flying Saucer Candies were the ultimate retro sweet treat, often found in candy shops with their unmistakable, disc-shaped candy wafers. What made these little treats unique was the powdery, slightly tangy filling inside, which would dissolve on your tongue as you bit into the crisp, thin wafer. They had a fun, quirky look and were a favorite for those who loved a candy that was both playful and nostalgic.
6. Peanut Butter Twix
Long before the cookie butter craze hit, there was Peanut Butter Twix. Imagine the classic Twix bar, but instead of caramel, there was smooth peanut butter. For fans of the salty-sweet combo, this version was perfection, but it was discontinued in 2000. Sigh.
7. 100 Grand Bar
The 100 Grand Bar was the perfect balance of chewy caramel, crunchy rice crisps, and rich milk chocolate. Its satisfying texture and sweet, indulgent flavor made it a beloved treat for many years. While it’s still available today, it was originally discontinued in certain areas before making a comeback. The unique combination of caramel and crispy rice set it apart from other candy bars, and its nostalgic appeal still has fans wishing it had a more prominent place on the candy shelves during its early years.
8. Jolly Rancher Bites
Jolly Rancher Bites were an incredible twist on the classic Jolly Rancher hard candy. These chewy, bite-sized morsels combined the intense fruity flavors we loved with a softer texture. If you enjoyed a burst of sour or sweet flavor, these chewy bites had your back until they were discontinued in the early 2010s.
9. S’mores Crunch Bar
When you wanted to indulge in a campfire classic without the fire, S’mores Crunch Bars had you covered. The crunchy graham cracker bits, gooey marshmallow, and rich chocolate made for the perfect candy bar. They were a nostalgic treat for many, but unfortunately, they were discontinued in the mid-2000s.
10. O’Henry Bar
The O’Henry Bar was a nostalgic treat that packed a punch with its crunchy peanuts, chewy caramel, and rich chocolate coating. It was a classic combination of textures and flavors that made it a favorite among candy lovers for many years. Unfortunately, the O’Henry Bar was discontinued in the U.S. in the late ’90s, though it continues to be available in some other countries. Its unique mix of sweet and salty elements made it a standout candy bar that’s still missed by many.
11. Marathon Bar
Before it became a Snickers, the Marathon Bar was the ultimate chewy caramel, chocolate, and crispy nougat bar that you could savor during a long road trip or a movie marathon. Its twisted shape and delicious blend of textures were hard to beat, and it’s no wonder candy lovers still mourn its discontinuation in the ’80s.
12. Cinnamon Tic Tacs
Tic Tacs have always been a fan favorite, but the cinnamon-flavored variety was something special. Those tiny, powerful mints packed a spicy punch, and their unmistakable flavor is still remembered fondly by fans of bold, cinnamon candies. Sadly, they were discontinued, but the memory of that sharp, warm burst of flavor still lingers.
13. Cherry 5th Avenue
The 5th Avenue candy bar was always a great option for those who wanted something with a mix of rich chocolate and crispy peanut butter. But when the cherry variety came into the picture, it elevated the candy to another level. The fruitiness of the cherry combined with the crunch of peanut butter made this one unforgettable—until it was discontinued, of course.
14. Nutty Buddy
Nutty Buddy bars were a simple yet perfect combination of crispy wafer and peanut butter coating. They were small, affordable, and perfect for anyone who wanted a quick, satisfying snack. Though Nutty Buddy no longer graces the shelves, its unique take on the classic peanut butter and wafer combo is remembered fondly.
15. Zagnut
Zagnut was a candy bar that combined toasted coconut and crunchy peanut butter, making for a unique flavor combo. Its crisp, coconut-covered exterior and peanut butter center made it a standout among the classic candy bars of the ’60s and ’70s. Although Zagnut still exists today, its popularity has waned, and it’s often considered a discontinued candy by those who fondly remember it from its heyday.
